diff --git a/fowl/game/models.py b/fowl/game/models.py
index e97ccf5..74f876e 100644
--- a/fowl/game/models.py
+++ b/fowl/game/models.py
@@ -33,6 +33,11 @@ class Star(models.Model):
         return self.division != 'other'
 
     def win_title(self, title, date, tag_partner=None):
+        # if they have title on that date (or won it then), don't add anything
+        if (self.has_title(date) or
+            self.reigns.filter(title=title, begin_date=date).count()):
+            return
+
         # end current title reigns
         TitleReign.objects.filter(title=title).update(end_date=date)
         self.reigns.create(title=title, begin_date=date)
diff --git a/fowl/game/tests.py b/fowl/game/tests.py
index f10c5a2..1aa4bb7 100644
--- a/fowl/game/tests.py
+++ b/fowl/game/tests.py
@@ -25,6 +25,12 @@ class StarTest(TestCase):
         self.assertEqual(Star.objects.get(pk='cmpunk').has_title(), None)
         self.assertEqual(Star.objects.get(pk='danielbryan').has_title(), 'wwe')
 
+        # test multiple win does nothing
+        dbry.win_title('wwe', datetime.date(2012,1,1))
+        dbry.win_title('wwe', datetime.date(2012,2,1))
+        dbry.win_title('wwe', datetime.date(2012,3,1))
+        self.assertEqual(dbry.reigns.count(), 1)
+
         # tag belt win
         self.assertEqual(Star.objects.get(pk='kofi').has_title(), 'tag')
         self.assertEqual(Star.objects.get(pk='rtruth').has_title(), 'tag')